410: Paper #2

History 410: Paper #2, Fall, 2022

For this assignment you will write a to 1000- to 1250-word essay on the establishment of American democracy during the Revolutionary period. Every good paper starts with a good critical question. A good critical historical question cannot be answered with just a yes or no, or a fact or series of facts. It does not just elicit an opinion or hinge on a subjective moral judgement. A critical question examines ambiguity, leads to more questions, provokes discussion, requires careful and skeptical reading of texts, requires contextualizing and interpretation of relevant historical facts, could be answered in more than one way. Make sure you understand these as critical questions that are answerable using evidence from class readings. Hint: if there seems to be only one plausible answer to the question then you are not thinking of it as a critical question.

  1. Assuming Carl Becker was correct and the Revolution was at least in part a struggle over "who should rule at home," examine the events of the Critical Period (the 1780s) to understand the nature of that struggle. Who were the combatants and what did they want? Which side embodied the true values of the Revolution as you understand them? And who came out on top?

  2. To what extent was the Critical Period of the 1780s actually a "debt crisis" (as defined by David Graeber) and the Constitution a response to that crisis? How does that complicate our exceptionalist view of the Constitution as "the most miraculous political document ever conceived"?

You are making an argument and so must support it convincingly with facts while acknowledging important contrary facts. In A Short Guide to Writing about History (a book most history teachers at Exeter owns), Richard Marius writes:

Historians and others use argument to take a position on a controversial topic. It can be said that every essay contains an argument in that every essay is built around a proposition that the writer wants us to believe. Yet in common usage, an argument is part of a debate, a dialogue between opposing views--sometimes many opposing views. Arguments include exposition, for they must explain the writer's point of view. An argument also seeks to prove that other points of view are wrong. Arguments are most interesting when the issues are important and all sides are fair to each other.

Thus it is important that you summarize opposing points of view fairly and completely. "Treat your adversaries as erring friends, not foes to be slain," Marius advises. "Always admit weakness in your argument and acknowledge those facts that opponents might raise against your position." For more on writing an argument go here.

Final papers should be turned in at my classroom by the end of classes on the due date. Include a heading with your name, the word count, and the number of the prompt you are answering. Papers should be typed and double spaced, with wide margins. Number the pages.